Times Tables, Mandelbrot and the Heart of Mathematics


ok so to start off I’ve got 4 images for you. Quick question what do all of
them have in common. Well, I would be very surprised if you guess this one here. (Giuseppe) They are full of lines. (M) They are full of lines, they are in a circle. But actually they are pictures of times
tables. I better explain this. So to get these pictures what
you do is you start with a circle and then you pick a random number. And we just choose something nice to start with, a 10. Then we put 10 points on the on
the perimeter here equally spaced and then we label them
with 1,2,3,4,5,6,7. Actually, let’s start with 0–0123456789 10 10 we also want, so we kind of put it
right there again. So that’s also 10, that’s also 11 12 13 14 15 and so on. And then
again, and so on. So this guy here stands for 1, 11, 21 and so on. And now we’re going to do the
two times table and we’ll start with 0. So 2 times 0 is 0, same thing, so we don’t do anything. OK, two times 1 is 2. So we connect the 1 to the 2. Then 2 times 2 is 4, connect the 2 to the 4 and we keep on going, pretty obvious. Now 2 times 5 is 10 and
remember 10 is also over there so we connect that guy up. And then 2 times 6 is 12 which is also the 2 and we just keep on going like this okay and then at 9 you pretty much
gone all the way around now you could go on so for example could now do 2
times 10 and 2 times 11 and 2 times 12 and draw in those connections but actually the connections
are going to be exactly the ones that we’ve drawn before. Just to illustrate, let’s just go up to 2 times 12 is 24 which corresponds to
the 4 and that connection is already there. 2 times 13 is 26, and we’ve already got that. Of course we made a choice at the beginning that 10 If you change that 10 to anything
else well the picture changes but pretty much
everything I said stays true. So for example if you switch from 10 to
11 we get this guy here here. And then 12 13 14 15 and let’s just see what happens. (Giuseppe) Is there a reason why the diagrams have a horizontal symmetry axis. (M) yep yep yep yep yep there’s a reason and let us give this as homework. Guys figure it out in the comments, tell us why there is a horizontal symmetry axis.
Of course, what’s much more interesting is that curve that
somehow magically materializes when you up the number that we chose at the beginning and actually just highlight it a bit. This strange curve got a name and pops
up all over mathematics, it’s called the cardioid like in cardiology and means heart. So it’s like a mathematical heart curve. It comes up in all kinds of places. I’ll just show you a few. Ok so for example you can
have it as a rolling curve rule one circle around another circle and just
see what happens to one of the points on the boundary of the rolling circle and what it does is it traces the cardioid. Now where else can you see it? Well sometimes you can see it in
your coffee cup. If you’ve got a conical coffee cup like this and the Sun is in the
directions of one of those green lines in the coffee cup then we can also see it. Where else? Right
there in the Mandelbrot set so the biggest bulb in the Mandelbrot set is a cardioid and the second one is a perfect circle. Now this would be a good one to figure out why why is this guy
a cardioid. Just chase this down somewhere. Now just for those people who know something about the stuff, that’s the equation that we use to make up the Mandelbrot set
and there is a 2 in there. That’s important We just had the two times table. Let’s
keep going now (Giuseppe) One more thing about the cardioid shape. As a video producer I know that there is a microphone called cardioid microphoes and that is because they pick up the sound in that area, from that direction. (M) Okay maybe we do another video on this. Now instead of doing the two times table we can do the the three times table. What we get is this pattern here for initial our
choice 10 and then I just up up the numbers and what do we get? Another curve, another very famous
curve. This is called the nephroid which means kidney. It’s also a rolling curve, here the circle that is rolling is half the size of the other one. It’s also in a generalized Mandelbrot set. Remember before we head an exponent of 2. Now we’re
talking about the three times table we change the exponent to 3 and you actually
get the main bulb here being the nephroid. We also get it in the coffee cup. This time we need a straight straight coffee cup and the light
rays come in from one side. So they come in straight like this and
then they of bounce around inside the cup and and make up this curve.
Actually this way of making up a curve is called a catacaustic in mathematics. What else have we got. Four times you can see a pattern now. Four times gets you three petals. Before we had three times and so two petals and all these other things that we’ve highlighted they work too. Here the the exponent has gone up to to 4 in the generalized Mandelbrot set. Here we’ve got the rolling curve happening again. And then just for good measure
just one more guy here. That’s the 5. It gets four petals and we’ve got the Mandelbrot set here and we’ve got the rolling curve. All very neat. (Giuseppe) So the number of petals is n-1? Yep and it keeps on going like this. Ok so let’s start again with 2 times table. Now one one really nice thing to try is to actually
make increments not one … to 3 to 4 to 5 but actually do smaller increments actually do the transition here
continuously. I’ll just show you what it looks like when I do the multiplication times 2.1. What you get
would you get 2.1, 2.2, 2.3, 2.4, 2.5, 2.6, 2.7, 2.8, 2.9 and 3 and you can see how this cardioid turns into the nephroid. Now I just let it go. The numbers are going up and you can see the petals going more and more and more. You think well that’s probably what
it’s going to be. You can also look at this in the Mandelbrot set and you
can actually see exactly this sort of pattern happening in the middle. As we push the exponent to infinity the
whole thing kind of turns into one big circle. Okay and now you think that’s
the end of it but no, no, no. Let’s keep going here. Now the petals are pretty much going away but if you just look at what’s happening here
you see there’s a lot more structure somehow being hinted at. I mean I’m
moving very fast at the moment moving very fast but if you actually went
through this frame-by-frame you would see a lot of really really nice structure
happening and I’ve highlighted a bit here. Just a few of the frames that you get
you know some really amazing stuff happening here so if you stop at 33 you get this one. If you stop at 34 and there are a couple of other highlights here. There are a lot more but that is how
many I could fit here. Ok maybe let’s have a close look at some of them. So here we’ve got four. The number that all these correspond to is 200. What we’re really doing he has a
special name in mathematics So what we’re doing here is
the times table modulo 200. So it’s got a special name. It’s actually incredibly
important in all sorts of applications to do this sort of modular arithmetic.
But paper anyway for our purposes you know you understand how it’s built up
and if you know a little bit more you know a little bit more. So for the 2 times table we get the cardioid. For the 34 times table modulo 200 we get this guy here and then
some other interesting things happen. So, for example, if you multiply by 51 we get this guy here and if you multiply by 99 you
get that guy here. And obviously if you just look at the two numbers here below so 51 is pretty close to 1/4 of 200 so must have something to do is that. 99
is pretty close to one-half of 200, must have something to do with that. Now I
really want to explain something I really want to explain where this one
comes from. And well I mean the first time I saw it I was pretty surprised like
everybody else who sees it but then I remembered something I had seen the cardioid before in you know many many different guises and in one particular one that I was familiar
with I could see where the connection is. I just want to tell you about that one
and it’s got to do with these light rays bouncing around. It’s a little bit different
from what we had before. So basically we’ve got a circle here and then we’ve got a light
source right over on that side. And that circle reflects the light right, so we switch on
the light over there and then well what happens? Well light rays emanate in all kinds of directions and get reflected off the circle bounce around and you can see
this pattern emerging, the cardioid. So I knew this one I had actually calculated
this curve from this description at some point in university. And starting with this you can actually see very easily why the cardioid comes up in the two times table and I just want to show you.Let’s just highlight like one of those rays coming out here. It hits the wall here
and then it gets reflected at the same angle as it comes in, so this angle that you see here is the same as it comes in. So what does that tell us now? Well, if we if we put this line in the middle that means that this side really flips over
to that side, which means that this segment in particular is exactly as long
as that one here. If I travel from this light bulb to this point and then from
this point to that point it’s exactly the same distance, that’s going to be important. So let’s make this 0 let’s call this N. What’s 2N then? To get 2N we have to measure this distance here and then we have to measure it again and where do we get?
Right up there ! And so it’s pretty clear that when you do the 2 times thing you get that reflected ray, you know, in the picture. Just to finish off I’ll show you a little bit of a movie of all the stuff evolving a little bit slower than what
we had before.

100 thoughts on “Times Tables, Mandelbrot and the Heart of Mathematics”

  1. I see a cardioid pickup pattern emerge. But I'm a sound guy so that's pretty natural for me to spot after looking at tons of microphone pickup patterns.

  2. It's so weird when you discover these things for yourself and then look it up and other people have found it already. I was messing with geometer's sketchpad as a freshmen in high school by using two concentric circles and a line between the two and animating both points around the circle while tracing the line. Kudos to all those who discover these things for themselves even if they've already been found by someone else. Discovery is so much more rewarding than having someone else tell you everything.

  3. i once made a program that displayed this table with constantly increasing values and after a while it got reset to its starting positions even though the times value was well above 1000

  4. That was mesmorizing, spiral is shown in the animation at the end of video, lots of cool stuff there …thank you for sharing your knowledge

  5. flowers are made like this by nature…and flowers want to be beautiful so can attract things towards them.. so this geometry is literally the definition of beauty as even nature knows how to use it to make things beautiful….divine geometry it isss….

  6. 3:46 I may be thinking of something else, but I always thought this kind of curve was called a limacon. Guess I have to read up on limacons now. May be a good topic for a future video.

  7. If you notice the animation the spirals of petals repeat themselves in an anticlockwise then clockwise direction. This is probably from the fact that 2 times tables and 12 etc end 24680 and 8 times tables end 86420 they reciprocate each other. Same for 1 and 9, 3 and 7, 4 and 6.

  8. Hi! Very interesting  to look at the patterns you are presenting. Where did you get them from? As a matter of fact I discovered the same prime mandalas some 30 years ago which I show on my prime website http://www.prime-numbers.eu. Yes, the patterns are there, but what about the math behind? I have talked to professors and other well known mathematics about this but they could give no explanation. Can you? Exciting though to find some of these patterns presented in the way you do it. You may contact me according to the mailadress you find on my website.  Look forward to hear from you. Thanks a lot. Gunnar

  9. The main cardioid in the Mandelbrot set is the region of parameters c for which Pc has an attracting fixed point. It consists of all parameters of the form c= μ/2 (1 – μ/2) for some μ in the open unit disk.

  10. I ate 8 grams of mushrooms and took a hit of dmt about 2 hours in and once the dmt trip was over, i immediately grabbed a pen and paper and started drawing a bunch of shit like this with this weird equation I had in my head. Idk, it was pretty profound. Like… I had never really felt more certain on my understanding of anything as much as I suddenly did this. I noticed that I couldn’t feel the mushrooms anymore either. I spent the next year trying to study into this topic but had no idea how to utilize it or even make it applicable to regular life lol. But then, I found this video. And suddenly many more like it. It’s a fucking godsend! I still don’t know necessarily what to do with that experience and the knowledge it blessed me with, but I couldn’t be more thankful.

    Thanks universe. 🙏🤘

  11. Traders make a shit ton of money using mandelbrot stuff, this one guy made an alghorithm auto trader with it called aligator, kind of funny to find out quantum physicists, traders, artists, mathematicians and hippies all meeting at this one point in the end.

  12. http://www.rlefebvre.ca/modulorama.htm

    allows you to visualize these fantastic figures that can be projected in addition to a circle, a triangle, a square or parallels…

  13. It reminds us of the mathematics of nature. I'm just sorry my math teachers didn't show us stuff like this.

  14. Cardiod microphones work in this way. Microphones in general seem to bear these properties.[Posted comment before guy in the room said, 'like a cardioid mic']

  15. 💯✫•*¨`*•.¸ ✅👍•*¨`*••*¨*•.¸¸¸.•´*¨`*• Cardioid is your resulting 51 number. Fascinating to see the Mandelbrot Fibonacci nature of mathematics. Many use this in Sacred Geometry and Qi Gong movements and meditation techniques.

  16. In school we are taught different branches of mathematics: arithmetic, algebra, geometry, trig, calculus and so on but math is an all encompassing world smoothly connecting all those artificially defined branches.

  17. Heck. I know probably no one will see this comment, but I've found a pattern in what shape emerges for the number of lines/dots 'l' and the number to multiply by "n".
    Whenever l = 2n+1, we get a cardioid. And I suspect I can find equations like this for other patterns, too.
    Is there an equation for the "curve" you'll get for a specific l and n?

  18. How the hell did i get here? I like it though. I don't even know my times tables but i love to see stuff like this. I just hope some of it gets stuck in my brain.

  19. Look what I did:
    http://ivandimitrov.co.uk/projects/cardioid.html
    Have fun guys.
    For anyone interested in the code, feel free to contact me.

  20. tbh im not really convinced by symmetry… what is the proof that the two sides are really symmetrical and we arent being just a little inaccurate or being fooled by our senses

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *